These brownies are very good. We purchased two variations. They are that good that you must Pace yourself. I definitely would recommend them.

2025-07-18

Upon receiving my items. They were extremely melted and the brownies lost their shape and texture. The appearance of the brownies advertised on their site is what drew me to purchasing these. And I was dissatisfied. There should be a much better way of transporting these food items. I was not satisfied with the taste and overall appearance.

2025-09-02

I’ve been watching ads for months and was hesitant to pull the tigger on an order. I finally did it and yes! They are as good as they look! They are also as big as they look. My wife and step son shared these with me and everyone enjoyed them. 10/10

2025-07-26

I absolutely love these brownies ! They have so much flavor and are so thick and delicious! I have ordered 3 times already and plan on ordering more ! Well worth the money! You won’t be disappointed! Can’t wait to try the lemon ones next !

2025-07-24

Personally I wouldn't buy the brownies again they was good but not what I thought. The cookies are absolutely delicious though!

2025-04-15

Very good brownie but, would like to see less cookies and more of the peanut butter brownie filling.

2025-04-14

These brownies are huge!! That being said they tasted great but in my opinion seemed a little under cooked. I like chewy brownies but not raw. The flavor was spot on!!

2025-03-11

They tasted very great on would definitely recommend these brownies to a friend.

2025-02-27

Tasty. I did feel like it could use more peanut butter flavor, but I would buy these again.

2024-10-16

I feel that they tasted very old and dry. They were supposed to come on a Friday and they didn’t even end up coming until Monday so I don’t even know how old they were.

2024-10-04

I must say any brownies or treat you buy from buckeye brownies will be worth it

2024-09-10

I Got a notification on the 21st of August that it was being shipped. I did not receive it until the 26th. For something that's perishable I was thinking I would have got it much sooner.

2024-09-05

Almost gave a 5 star but I really wanted more brownie and less cookie bar.

2024-08-16

I love the brownies, I had to share with family and they all loved them.

2024-06-21

I have got to stop ordering this. You cannot eat just a little

2024-06-08

This brownie is everything. The peanut butter cookie on top is *chefs kiss* and just the ooey gooey deliciousness (throwing it in the oven is a must) is a whole next level experience! Absolutely delicious for a peanut butter lover!

2024-04-16

I was really looking forward to these brownies! They were all over my social media feed and they truly looked delicious! Every post/video I came across said nothing but great things about these brownies so I ordered the two pack of MVP and Mr. Buckeye (also paid extra for next day shipping so that they were extra fresh). I tried them after my bodybuilding show hoping it would fill that void. They came in and looked as pictured and were beautiful. We heated them as instructed and while the textures were okay…the taste of both of these brownies were extremely bland and underwhelming. I couldn’t taste the peanut butter or the Oreo flavors! To me, they weren’t even sweet! I was just so disappointed, and I say this as someone who ate them after not having sugar for 4 to 5 months!

2024-04-15

These tasted ok, not great but not bad. They were however, surprisingly dry. I wouldn’t buy them again.

2024-04-10

They taste so good the kids went crazy for them, we will definitely be ordering them again

2024-03-28

It was really good( honestly) . I wish my new order came in as fast as my first tho 😔

2024-03-18