
A**s **
·
Verified purchase
US
Stunning color. Very pigmented. It feels like nothing is on my eye. Easy to blend like butter. But last forever no runny liner.
2024-12-03

S**y L**g
·
Verified purchase
US
Excellent product color and wear time are the best I have tried in a long time
2026-01-09
I love the way it glides on the lid and I can use a brush to help sweep it where I need it. So far so good.
2025-12-19
Love the color but it’s doesn’t stand up 100% to my super watery eyes. For the price and the ease of application though it’s an excellent eyeliner.
2025-12-13

C**m **
·
Verified purchase
US
Most incredible eyeliner I’ve ever had! Goes on SO easy and smooth! 🥰
2025-08-28
Great eyeliner, long lasting and very easy to apply.
2024-12-26
This eye liner is great! The formula is so creamy and pigmented.
2024-12-16
Melt wonderwomen have done it again.
Cannot do without.
Now that I have found it , I will keep it
On my essential cosmetics list.
2023-04-06
I'm obsessed with these pencils. They glide on so effortlessly and the color pay off is amazing. Love to use all over the face!
2023-03-16
This pencil is sooooo soft, creamy and pigmented. I use it for my waterline but I also like smudging it on my top lid and it blends like perfection!
2023-03-12
The best waterline eyeliner there is! I wish they would make it in black
2023-03-08
I LOVE the pencil. The only thing I recommend, it to make SURE you have a cleansing balm or makeup remover, because this does NOT come off with regular face wash. But it is a GREAT product 🥰
2023-03-07
Glides on like liquid silk right after you pop the cap.. I just ordered two more colors as it is such a dream to apply.
2023-02-20
I love this pencil! It stays put wherever you place it, you don’t have to scrub to get it off. I love it just like all of the melt cosmetics I have tried! It’s in my daily makeup bag!
2023-02-02
The waterline pencils are sooo good. And the versatility is unmatched in a pencil.
2022-12-26
I love these pencils very soft and smooth lines, no smudging
2022-12-25
So creamy and easy to blend. Also, they stay so well in my waterline!
2022-12-12
Color and application are great! I do need to reapply directly on my waterline after a while, but it stays really well everywhere else.
2022-11-05
Loved this pencil. So smooth and no tugging. And it lasted a long time. Only downside is that it breaks easily.
2022-10-27