If I could give a zero star, I would a liner came broken, chewed up
2025-12-09
The best there is. Long stay and really makes blue eyes pop!!!
2025-11-21
I love this product it’s highly pigment and glides on smoothly
2025-11-17
Beautiful brown color with a hint of a red/burgundy. I never thought I would really like another eyeliner color besides black.
2025-11-10

K** B**s
·
Verified purchase
US
Beautiful eyeliner color. Goes on smooth. Great deal. Going try some of the other colors. Long wear
2025-09-05
I received my pencil and it measured shorter to my other Mac pencils
2026-01-13
First time buying this but it won’t be my last easy glide great one time applying didn’t have any issues with my contacts
2026-01-11
Love MAC eyeliners! This liner pairs perfectly with Sable!!
2026-01-07
It’s a very nice brown but on my medium olive tone it kinda looks a purplish brown. It def makes my brown eyes pop.
2025-12-14
This starting running on my eyes after 2 hours. Glides on great.
2025-12-10
Have been looking for this shade for some time now and it has been out at the mall I shop at. So when I saw it here on TT I snatched it up immediately. Have not used it yet, but did try it on my hand. So far it looks amazing!
2025-12-06
The reddish brown is absolute perfection with brown eyes! The product is a true kohl eyeliner but glides really smooth for kohl. Sharpens great. Good staying power. This is my second purchase of this liner
2025-11-28

E**e B**
·
Verified purchase
US
As a soft summer girly this is absolutely perfect. It is not too harsh for my features, I can still do a fun little wing without looking garish. That's always the formula is great.
2025-11-22

𝕄**𝕒 📚**
·
Verified purchase
US
Costa riche is like the shade Teddy only without the shimmer. I have used Mac for decades and I’m always happy with their products.
2025-11-19
Smooth pencil in a great color. Find I have to apply to lower lid rather than water line or it doesn’t last. Have sensitive skin and eyes and have not had any issues
2025-11-06

E**n S**n R**o B**h
·
Verified purchase
US
My favorite for over 20 years. I’ve tried cheaper eyeliners and I always come back to this one.
2025-10-05
Big fan of Mac amazing products quality of the pigment is amazing
2025-09-25
Best eyeliner soft smooth easy to used eyeliner
2025-11-07
Mac eye liner always a good idea.
2026-01-14
All brown eyed girlys neeeddd this!
2025-10-09