4.5
122 global reviews
5
98
4
9
3
5
2
3
1
7
Photos from reviews
L**a K**y W**r
Sort by
Recommended
Filter by
All
Displaying 122 of 122 reviews
Reset filters
L**h
·
Verified purchase
US
The application wand was bent when opened Unable to use
Item:
Mauve + Sandstone2026-01-02
M**g
·
Verified purchase
US
I liked the colors but compared to other cream shadows I’ve used, these were super dry and didn’t blend well. They honestly dried way too quickly and looked patchy
Item:
Chestnut + Sandstone2025-12-22
L**a K**y W**r
·
Verified purchase
US
Ran to get package to use in my morning routine . I LOVE THEM
Item:
Chestnut + Sandstone2025-11-17
m**s
·
Verified purchase
US
Tube was empty. Ordered replacement which was empty as well.
Item:
Mauve + Sandstone2026-02-03
C**y L**
·
Verified purchase
US
Love this eyeshadow! It goes on easily and lasts all day. Will definitely be purchasing some more colors.
Item:
Chestnut + Sandstone2026-01-25
C**y L**
·
Verified purchase
US
Love this eyeshadow. It goes on so easily and lasts all day. Definitely must have.
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2026-01-25
S**y L**
·
Verified purchase
US
Love the product. I’ve been having problems with eyeshadows as I’ve aged that crease and wear off. Mario’s eyeshadow stays all day. Will definitely try more of his products.
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2026-01-24
N**y N**y M**s
·
Verified purchase
US
Don’t care for it, made my eyes irritated. Going to return it
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2026-01-23
u**2
·
Verified purchase
US
Love how easy this is to apply/ love the colors - getting more and so easy to travel with!
Item:
Mauve + Sandstone2026-01-14
F**n
·
Verified purchase
US
New holy grail product. So impressed. I used the espresso as an eyeliner. Stayed all day and looked amazing. Love! 💝
Item:
Chestnut + Espresso2026-01-12
t**s
·
Verified purchase
US
These cream eyeshadow are amazing! They go on effortlessly and look beautiful!
Item:
Sienna + Sandstone2026-01-10
A**a R**o
·
Verified purchase
US
This is a great concept it just does not work the way shown on tiktok. Very hard to blend very cakey and smudgy.
Item:
Chestnut + Espresso2026-01-07
j**s
·
Verified purchase
US
This blends so nice and adding different colors blend nicely. Dries quickly. Love the colors
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2026-01-07
C**e
·
Verified purchase
US
Great cream eyeshadow for beginners. Very pigmented and easy to blend.
Item:
Sienna + Sandstone2026-01-05
N**e **
·
Verified purchase
US
Good coverage. Beginner friendly. I’ve used them almost everyday since I bought them.
Item:
Sienna + Sandstone2026-01-04
J**a
·
Verified purchase
US
WOW!!! absolutely beautiful application, simple with great impact on the eye. Makeup by Mario never disappoints.
Item:
Mauve + Sandstone2026-01-04
E**3
·
Verified purchase
US
Absolutely love these eye creams, they are long wearing, smudge proof and a must have neutral colors. Can’t wait for a shimmer color to come out?
Item:
Chestnut + Sandstone2026-01-03
B**2
·
Verified purchase
US
Videos were accurate! Smooth application that it’s hard to mess up. You should blend it in quickly because it dries fast and won’t blend if it’s dry. I highly recommend! The shades are definitely matte like I wanted and blend perfectly together giving a professional look! I Would purchase again.
Item:
Chestnut + Sandstone2025-12-30
u**0
·
Verified purchase
US
Okay~ not as smooth as expected on mature skin even w lots of prep before using.
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2025-12-30
A**y B**s
·
Verified purchase
US
The best eye shadow I have ever used!! I have since purchased 4 additional colors!
Item:
Bisque + Mauve2025-12-29
About this product
Combined Variations:Chestnut + Espresso
Bisque + MauveChestnut + Espresso
Mauve + Sandstone
Chestnut + Sandstone
Sienna + SandstoneQuantity:
Coupon center
Log in to check your coupons
View and claim any available offers once you're logged in.
Shipping & returns
Shipping & delivery
Many items qualify for free shipping or become eligible once the order threshold is met.
Returns made easy
Most items are eligible for free returns within 30 days of delivery for a refund. Some items, including ingestibles, hygiene products, and pre-owned goods, are non-returnable. Final sale items cannot be returned or replaced. Please log in to view this item's specific return policy.
Makeup By Mario
OFFICIAL SHOP
4.6
63.3K Sold
1.9M Followers
81%24h response rate
0%Ships within 2 days
90%Positive feedback
Visit
Shop review
Videos for this product
Creator earns commission
Junior Macias
7.2K
Creator earns commission
Sydneyslayyyz
5.4K
Creator earns commission
Bri Riley
4.3K
Creator earns commission
Sydneyslayyyz
4.0K
Creator earns commission
Humblemenails
1.6K
Creator earns commission
Byvivas
1.2K
Creator earns commission
Raghad Alnuaimi🦋
1.2K
Creator earns commission
Josselyn
760
Creator earns commission
kimberlyannchristian🗝️
568
Creator earns commission
Sarah Ramos
551
Creator earns commission
Big Hair by Ash
353
Creator earns commission
Sara Trotter
251
Creator earns commission
Kristi Dmytrenko ⊹₊⟡⋆
249
Creator earns commission
Humblemenails
218
Creator earns commission
Kripa Patel Joshi
191
Creator earns commission
Brianna Mazzoni
171
Creator earns commission
Sara Trotter
170
Creator earns commission
Lush October
169
Creator earns commission
Lush October
166
Creator earns commission
CiCi
163
Explore more from Makeup By Mario
You may also like
Painted
4.8
31.3K sold
$42.00
Tarte Cosmetics
4.7
77.3K sold
-55%$33.00$73.00
Persona Cosmetics
4.1
2.6K sold
-28%$35.19$49.00
Juvia’s Place
4.9
9.2K sold
$30.00
Jeffree Star Cosmetics
4.9
670 sold
-15%$44.40$52.00