Absolutely vibrant and intense. Lasts all day. The enternal sunshine color is more of a warm yellow and not a neon (which I love).

2026-02-09

I've had 3 line artists in sadgrl, into the void, and blue is the new black. Blue is the new black is BY FAR my favorite of the three; it's a beautiful navy that isn't immediately obvious like sadgrl is, and the subtle difference it makes on my brown eyes from traditional black liner is gorgeous. Sadgrl unfortunately has not been consistently pigmented; I have to reline a lot to get an opaque line (before even attempting a wing). It kind of "skips" when applied overtop of itself, like it takes off the pigment you've already applied. That makes for a difficult application that ultimately isn't worth it for the look. Into the void is fine as far as pigment goes, but it breaks off like crazy. I've struggled to get on just two of the tiniest wings without it breaking off 3-5 times. I've tried rolling up just enough to smudge for a messy lower liner, and it somehow manages to break even then. It's hard not to feel like a waste of product and money by the time I've fudged even just a simple line.

2025-12-30

I absolutely love the line Artist line and would love to see an expansion! My current fav I’ve ordered multiple times is Electric Slide!! It’s the perfect chartreuse and makes any look pop, severely underrated!

2025-12-25

My experience has been a good one, love this product

2025-11-26

Unfortunately runs very dark - reads as black on the lid/waterline even when blended out. Forumla is nice but I was looking for a nice deep blue.

2025-11-25

I love a good brown eyeliner because I have hazel eyes and sometimes black is a little harsh. This glides so effortlessly but is pigmented enough to make your eyes pop.

2025-11-18

Unflinching eyeliner for the unstoppable force of you. Favorite crayon-style eyeliner I’ve ever used!

2025-11-09

It’s a great color for those with black and brown eyes! The only thing was that when I tried to apply it to my waterline, I had to do it a couple of times. The color didn't show well which was a little disappointing since I high hopes for this one.

2025-10-30

I was looking for a non-liquid eyeliner that is truly smudge proof - and THIS IS IT!! My eyelids are not as taut as they used to be, so I needed something that sticks and doesn’t travel all over my face. I also still like to have fun with my makeup and like to wear other colors than black or brown. I bought this purple color and the bright royal blue which I LOVE. Thank you About Face for making such a high quality product for us more seasoned peeps. 🫶🏽🫰🏽🩵

2025-09-21

The pencil is fantastic as the color glides on so smoothly & stays in place for the entire day. I'm so glad I found your brand & will continue to purchase these differently colored pencils when needed.

2025-09-16

not the best quality. not very pigmented and when it's on, it becomes crumbly!!! you have to go over it a bunch of times just to make it look pigmented

2025-09-01

super pretty, doesnt smudge unless you smudge it yourself, doesnt turn grey when applied.

2025-08-14

This is a great formula with lots of pigment. I can get it really close to my lashes and smudge it out to create a really pretty wing that lasts. I wore this on a really hot day and it didn't budge. Love the color, too.

2025-08-06

This is the only eyeliner I’ll ever use! So great and doesn’t smudge nearly as much as other brands.

2025-08-06

This is my go too on hot days, stays put!! Stays vibrant!! I want every color

2025-07-22

This eyeliner is not for me. It flaked badly. Little flecks all day under and in my eyes. It also smeared under the eye.

2025-07-11

Stays nicely, not really any drag, however a lot darker than i thought. More a super dark rust orange. May try another color as that is the only reason I gave it four stars.

2025-06-17

I love these liners . The colors are wonderful and they really last!

2025-06-02

Good product but the tip instantly broke off, maybe i was applying too much pressure but overall still good!

2025-05-15

I love how easy it goes on. I have a lot of allergies, and have never had a reaction from this eyeliner. It still looks fresh even after running around, sweating for hours!

2025-02-21