Review highlights

C**4

This is my second time ordering this I just love this flavor

Monster Cheesecake Peanut Butter TreatJanuary 21, 2026

J**e

I liked this one. I like anything cheesecake flavored (most of the time).

Monster Cheesecake Peanut Butter TreatOctober 6, 2025

A**e

The Brownies are in the Freezer for Valentine's Day Dinner. They're going to be dessert, for, After dinner. They look exactly like the TikTok pictures!

Buckeye's Fantastic Four PackFebruary 5, 2026

K**x g**🥰

Thank you🥳Buckeye brownies🍪Company🥧I’m in✉️love with🧧my Buckeye✨brownies thank💍 you🍻so much🍸

Buckeye's Fantastic Four PackJanuary 3, 2026

‧**͙

Probably one of the most scrumptious gluten free treats I’ve had in a while. As someone with celiac disease, this thing HIT THE SPOT

Cosmallow Brownie Cups (set of 2)February 13, 2025

W**a N**n

OMG they are amazing. I absolutely love the cherry and the brownie mellow. Oh my God and I still have yet more to try. I’ve only gotten through two cause I got these as Valentine treats and I love them and I’ll be ordering.more ❤️‍🔥‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️

Cosmallow Brownie Cups (set of 2)February 9, 2025

R**d

These are THEE best caramel apples I’ve ever eaten. Packaging was great and delivery was excellent. They are so big and fresh. You can tell the are were freshly made❤️

Cheesecake Gourmet Bundle: Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, & Cookies & Cream CheesecakeSeptember 10, 2025

S**e

Humongous apples, fast shipping (received in 2 days), apples delicious 😋 as always!

Cheesecake Gourmet Bundle: Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, & Cookies & Cream CheesecakeMarch 11, 2026

B**s A**e

I had been eyeing these for a while and I finally made the plunge & was not disappointed. The cookie dough marshmallow was delicious. A little bummed because they were smashed inside (box not damaged) so I didn't get the "crunch" I saw from influencers but didn't affect the overall taste. Yum!

Oh Dough You Didn't Edible Cookie Dough Cups (set of 2)March 6, 2026

9**l

Chocolate is rich! Great match for my evening tea.

Oh Dough You Didn't Edible Cookie Dough Cups (set of 2)December 21, 2025